Hint 1
Compare all the statements carefully. Did you notice that if A is lying, then B would also be lying?
"Hey! Somebody ate my piece of cake! I was saving that for later!"
A: "I didn't eat it!"
B: "Neither A nor D ate it."
C: "I didn't eat it either!"
D: "C is telling the truth."
Somebody isn't telling the truth. That person is the cake gobbler. Who is it? Circle a person and touch <CR>Submit</C>.

Compare all the statements carefully. Did you notice that if A is lying, then B would also be lying?
If D is lying, then C would be lying.
If C is lying, then D would be lying.
Also, you'll soon realise that if B is lying there is more than one cake eater and therefore more than one liar.
Are they all liars?! No. Only one person involved in this puzzle is lying.
Out of A, B, C and D, maybe nobody is lying...
But somebody ate the cake!
A, B, C and D are all telling the truth. But somebody is definitely lying.
Who else is there?
You got it!
"The somebody who ate the cake is me. I wasn't saving it for later at all!"
Thinking logically, once you realise that A, B, C and D are all telling the truth, the person who is lying must be the one who originally complained!

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.