Hint 1
Getting in and out of a suit of armor while wearing a hat would be nearly impossible.
A good sleuth will use the process of elimination to find the culprit.
Somebody threw on this suit of armor in the exact same attire they're wearing now and put a dent in the helmet!
All you need is a close look at the perpetrator to find out who it was.
Which of these four lads was it?

Getting in and out of a suit of armor while wearing a hat would be nearly impossible.
A good sleuth will use the process of elimination to find the culprit.
You can disregard lad C because he couldn't even fit in the armor.
Whoever was wearing the helmet when he dented it probably hurt himself too.
Who could it be?
The lads are all facing the opposite way of the armor, so don't get the position of the dent confused.
Correct!
The culprit was D.
There is a bump on his head matching the dent in the helmet, but he was hiding it with his hand!

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.