Hint 1
Listen carefully to their testimonies, in order...
One of these students broke a window, so you ask each of them who did it, in order.
A: "I didn't do it." B: "A is telling the truth." C: "D is lying." D: "It certainly wasn't me."
The one whose story sounds fishy is the culprit. Who is it?

Listen carefully to their testimonies, in order...
Look again at the content of each testimony and the order in which they are given.
Do that, and you'll soon notice that one of them is saying something not quite right.
The culprit is the one who spoke in haste. If you'd heard the testimonies in the opposite order, the culprit might never have given themselves away.
The culprit gave the game away while trying to pin the blame on D.
C
That's right!
C broke the window. He said that D was lying, even though D hadn't spoken yet.
It doesn't get any fishier than that!

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.