Hint 1
Each gentleman is holding something different. Concentrate on those items.
"I was considered quite the catch in my younger days, you know! This is a picture of me back then, along with three of my handsome suitors. A few moments after this photo was taken, one of these gents expressed his love for me by presenting me with a heart."
Which one of these men, A-C, is the suitor in question?

Each gentleman is holding something different. Concentrate on those items.
The heart she's talking about isn't drawn on anything that the gentlemen are holding. She must be referring to something shaped like a heart. Hmm... How can you make a heart shape?
One of the three gentlemen is holding something that could easily be turned into a heart shape.
Take another look.
It wasn't a beautiful bouquet or an enchanting melody that charmed her.
It was a loving gesture!
A
Lovely answer!
It was him all right!
He made a heart out of the magazine he was holding. Quite a creative gesture, eh?
There's no inspiration like true love...

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.