Hint 1
If it weren't for those parts sticking out, you could make two rather chubby 1s... But that's not the answer.
This board can be cut in a way that produces two identical number-shaped pieces.
Where do you need to cut the board in order to do this?
You can only cut along the dotted lines.

If it weren't for those parts sticking out, you could make two rather chubby 1s... But that's not the answer.
The number shape you're looking for is not 2 or 5.
The main problem here is working out which part of the number is represented by those two protrusions.
The number shape isn't 6 or 9.
You'd need an awful lot of squares to cut out two number shapes that have a hole in the middle.
One of the two number shapes has been turned upside down and slotted into the other one. If you think about this for a moment, you'll see that 3 can be ruled out.
A cut above!
You can create two pieces shaped like the number 4. Cutting the board as shown above is one way of doing this.

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.