Hint 1
The only thing to do with a puzzle like this is to narrow down the possible options. Take notes on which files meet the conditions you are given.
The police archives have a rather confusing filing system.
The file Emmy wants is two files away from a file with a 3 in its number. It is also three files away from a file with a 6 in its number and four files away from a file with a 9 in its number. All the mentioned files are on a single shelf.
Can you help find the file?

The only thing to do with a puzzle like this is to narrow down the possible options. Take notes on which files meet the conditions you are given.
It would be nice to narrow down the number of files that might meet your conditions. The most limiting factor is probably that the file must be "four files away from a file with a 9 in its number". Start with that one, and then cross-check it against the other conditions.
The next most limiting factor is that the file you want is "three files away from a file with a 6 in its number".
Applying this condition and the one discussed in Hint 2 should bring you down to three options.
Your last condition to apply is that your file is "two files away from a file with a 3 in its number".
Don't forget to check both the left and right of each file when applying the conditions.
Correct!
The correct file is number 29.
It would be nice if the filing system were a little easier to understand.

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.