Hint 1
A good sleuth uses a process of elimination to find the culprit.
"One time there was this palaver up at the manor. Some hoodlums thought it'd be hilarious to get dressed up in the old suits of armour and have a race. But one of 'em falls over and puts a big dent in one of the helmets. We had 'em all rounded up, but - honour among thieves and all that - not one of 'em will own up. Then the chief, he takes just one look at 'em and picks out the culprit."
Which of these four suspicious lads is the one who dented the armour?

A good sleuth uses a process of elimination to find the culprit.
It should be possible to disregard suspect C because it doesn't look like he could even wear the armour.
Whoever was wearing the helmet when he dented it probably hurt himself too. Who could it be?
The suspects are all facing the opposite way from the armour, so don't get the position of the dent confused.
Correct!
The culprit was D.
There's a bump on his head matching the dent in the helmet, but he was using his hand to hide it!

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.