Hint 1
The circular shape of the chandeliers may make it difficult to compare them.
Imagine making a cut somewhere along the circumference of each one and unrolling them all so they look like decorated belts.
"There's a lovely little chandelier in the dining room, and the master wants me to order another one just like it.
Trouble is, the catalogue has three different models and they all look the same to me! I can't for the life of me work out which one I'm supposed to be getting."
Out of the three chandeliers on the right, A, B and C, can you tell which is the same as the original model?

The circular shape of the chandeliers may make it difficult to compare them.
Imagine making a cut somewhere along the circumference of each one and unrolling them all so they look like decorated belts.
On the outer ring of the original chandelier, the crystal globe decorations and the lamps are hung alternately.
So, which chandelier in the catalogue shares this arrangement?
Call the lamp with the open shade O. Call the lamp with the closed shade C. Call the pendant with two globes 2. Call the pendant with three globes 3.
Going clockwise from the closed lamp on the original chandelier, the order of the decorations is: C, 2, O, 2, O, 3
Try comparing this with the other chandeliers.
The order for the original chandelier is C, 2, O, 2, O, 3. The order for A is C, 2, 2, O, O, 3. The order for C is C, 3, 2, O, 2, O.
The chandeliers are circular, so you can rotate them as much as you like. You must know the answer now!
Brilliant!
Chandelier B is exactly the same as the original chandelier.
Though if it's that hard to tell them apart, perhaps it wouldn't really have mattered which one Beth had ordered...

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.