Hint 1
B looks like it should fit together with its other half quite nicely.
Below are four halves of four separate cubes. Each of the halves is shaped so that when fitted with an identically shaped piece, these two halves form a whole cube. However, one piece below fails to meet those requirements and doesn't form a cube when joined with another identical piece.
Circle the odd piece out from choices A through D below.

B looks like it should fit together with its other half quite nicely.
D and another piece shaped like it would make a fine cube as well.
You're down to two possible answers at this point.
Choose the one that seems the least likely to fit with its twin.
That's right!
C will not form a cube when joined with another identical piece. Some areas of the shape are just a little too complex to fit together neatly.
Still, with only a few alterations, you could probably change that shape into something that works, don't you think?

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.