Hint 1
This is a hard puzzle, so maybe this hint will help. The first thing you need to do is create an answer key based on the three scored tests.
Since Mary got the highest score, try creating a key that compares her answers to everyone else's.
Four students took a test where every question had two possible answers, A or B. Each question was worth 10 points, for a total of 100 points.
The students' test results were posted as seen below, but the teacher forgot to tally Colin's score. Colin was heading to the teacher's office when Mary called him back, saying they could figure out his score using the results from the other tests. Can you figure out Colin's score?

This is a hard puzzle, so maybe this hint will help. The first thing you need to do is create an answer key based on the three scored tests.
Since Mary got the highest score, try creating a key that compares her answers to everyone else's.
The three graded tests agree on four questions. However, you know that not all four of these are correct because Lisa only got a score of 30 You also know that not all of these "agreed" answers are incorrect because Mary had a score of 70
You can make multiple answer keys that will all yield the same results. As long as you find one of these keys, you can solve this puzzle.
60
A+!
An A+ for you, that is. Unfortunately for Colin, his score was 60 points.
Based on the results from the three scored tests, you could come up with four possible answer keys, labeled here as A through D. No matter which one you use, Colin's score is 60!

Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.