Hint 1
The best way to solve a puzzle like this is to choose one of the suspects as your culprit and check whether or not your selection corresponds with the four men's statements.
A farmer comes back to his chicken coop to find the door open and all his chickens gone! He tells the sheriff, who works out either A, B, C or D is responsible, but they're all pointing fingers at each other:
A: "It's B who's to blame!" B: "C's the culprit. No doubt about it." C: "It's either A or B. I'm not sure which..." D: "It's B...or C. One of the two!"
Only one of these people is telling the truth. Can you work out who is to blame for this?
Select your answer by touching it with the stylus. If you wish to change your answer, just touch a different option.
Touch Submit when you're ready to see if your answer is correct.
The best way to solve a puzzle like this is to choose one of the suspects as your culprit and check whether or not your selection corresponds with the four men's statements.
Start by imagining that B is the culprit. That would make his statement false, and all the others' true.
However, you know only one of the men is telling the truth, so B cannot be the culprit.
Next, imagine C is the chicken-snatcher and a liar to boot.
This would mean that B and D are being honest, though, and since only one man is actually telling the truth, C must be innocent.
If D is lying and is, in fact, the culprit, that would mean that none of the four men are telling the truth.
But one of them is definitely being honest, so D is not the miscreant.
Eggs-actly!
A is the one who's responsible for the chickens' disappearance. He didn't steal them, though - he simply forgot to close the door!
A's punishment will be to get the chickens back and clean the coop from top to bottom. B and D will have to help him too. That'll teach them to lie!
Hints you open and puzzles you mark solved are kept in this browser.